« A Grand Slam Grand Marshal | Main | Atlanta Or Bust »
A Pitch For The Pioneers
So it's settled.
The NASCAR Hall Of Fame has been won by Charlotte, which is as it should be.
For decades the true heart of the sport has been the Queen City and the surrounding area, particularly Mooresville, where many teams are based and drivers make their homes on the shores of Lake Norman.
Now the intrigue shifts from the locale of the multi-million dollar hall to who will be chosen for the inaugural class of inductees.
There's no doubt about some who'll be selected for the honor:
Big Bill France Sr., the late NASCAR founder. Richard Petty and the late Dale Earnhardt, both seven-time champions at the sanctioning body's major level. David Pearson, whose 105 victories are second only to Petty's 200. Junior Johnson, who won 50 races as a driver and 136 more as a team owner who once captured six championships in a 10-year span.
Who else should be among the first enshrined?
Dozens are deserving of eventual induction into the hall that's scheduled to open in about three years in downtown Charlotte.
Although neither eligibility rules nor a selection format have been announced, permit me to make a pitch for the sport's pioneers to make up the bulk of the inaugural group of inductees.
Without them, who knows if stock car racing would have become a billion-dollar business that's now followed by fans worldwide.
Charter membership in the hall should go to Herb Thomas, Buck Baker, Tim Flock and Lee Petty, the biggest stars of the 1950s, all now deceased. All won multiple championships in that decade. The colorful, late Curtis Turner is another possibility.
Thomas, especially, deserves early induction. Through the years Baker, Flock and Lee Petty have become more familiar to modern-era fans, but Thomas was the sport's first big winner.
A North Carolina farm boy who worked at a sawmill during World War II, Thomas was in the field for NASCAR's first "Strictly Stock" race in Charlotte in 1949. He won his first race in 1950 and in '51 was the series champion.
Thomas' racing career continued to only 1956, when serious injuries in a crash forced him from the cockpit. But in his relatively brief time at the wheel he posted 48 victories, including three triumphs in the sport's toughest event, the Southern 500 at Darlington Raceway. He also won the championship in 1953 and was runnerup in the point standings three times.
Thomas and the other competitors in his era drove equipment that relatively was "Stone Age" compared to the safety standards and other sophistication of the cars of today. The drivers of the late 1940s, the '50s and even the '60s were brave almost beyond belief considering the protection that was affored to them. Also, they ran for "peanut-sized" purses, even when figuring for inflation.
For example, in his 1951 championship season Thomas earned a grand toal of $20,850. Tony Stewart, the Nextel Cup Series title-winner in 2005, pocketed almost $7 million.
Obviously, Thomas and the other pioneers drove race cars mostly for the passion and thrill of the chase.
Drivers from the 1960s deserving of membership in the hall include Ned Jarrett, Rex White, Fred Lorenzen and deceased greats Fireball Roberts, Joe Weatherly and Jim Paschal. And the late Wendell Scott, on the basis of the biases he had to battle and what he achieved with very limited resources.
Cale Yarborough and Bobby Allison lead the 1970s contingent that also includes Benny Parsons, Buddy Baker and the late Bobby Isaac.
Top candidates for the hall from the 1980s are Darrell Waltrip, Bill Elliott, Rusty Wallace and the late Neil Bonnett.
All these drivers I've mentioned undoubtedly will be inducted into the Charlotte hall at some point, along with such current stars as Jeff Gordon, Mark Martin, Dale Jarrett, Bobby and Terry Labonte, recent retiree Ricky Rudd and the late Davey Allison.
Great crew chiefs such as Dale Inman, Leonard Wood and the late Smokey Yunick deserve eventual induction, too, along with team owners like Bud Moore, Glen Wood, Rick Hendrick, Richard Childress, Raymond Parks, John Holman and Ralph Moody. Ditto track founders Bruton Smith and his deceased counterparts, Harold Brasington, Clay Earles and Enoch Staley.
There also should be a place in the hall for the talented champions of other NASCAR series, including Jack Ingram, Sam Ard, Jerry Cook and the late competitors Ralph Earnhardt, Richie Evans, Butch Lindley and Ray Hendricks.
But along with NASCAR founder France, Richard Petty, Dale Earnhardt, David Pearson and Junior Johnson, it's my hope that pioneer drivers from the top division such as Herb Thomas and his peers justly are remembered and honored first.
March 8, 2006 in Racing | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451bce769e200d83479a3ed53ef
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A Pitch For The Pioneers:
Comments
Curtiss Turner should be one of the first. The last should be the france family. The fans should be the ones voting on there drivers.But the France family will have (as always) there say and those drivers will be entered. AGAIN THE FANS WILL HAVE NO SAY!!
Posted by: mark | Mar 8, 2006 2:34:15 PM
Not only should the pioneers be included in the Hall but NASCAR should fund a retirement program for the Pioneers that need it.
Posted by: Alan Vordermeier | Mar 8, 2006 2:48:55 PM
You make good points but do not roget, NASCAR and it's history is not confined to the Grand National/Cup division only. Sure that has been the marquee but there are plenty of other divisions and drivers/crew chiefs/owners that have helped as much to make it the sport that it is today. How about Richie Evans? Sam Ard? Eddie Flemke? Bugs Stevens? Tommy Houston? The list goes on but the point is there are others that did not get their names in the national headlines each Monday who meant as much to the history of NASCAR in their own right.
Posted by: Miles Ross | Mar 8, 2006 4:29:10 PM
"The last should be the france family. The fans should be the ones voting on there drivers."
Ahhhh... NO, not unless the fans votes are weighted in some way. Say 10-20% of the total. The Hall doesn't need Dale Jr. elected the first year. And you KNOW it would happen if their input was the only criteria.
The same goes for the sports writers. If they have a vote at all it should be "weighted" in the same way. MLB has had a few deserving players not make it because they were perceived as less tahn friendly to the beat writers.
Pioneers? Yes and many are deserving. There is one category you missed Tom, "independents."
My selection in that category is Wendell Scott. He probably did more with less than any other NASCAR driver and had the added disadvantage of his race to overcome. He did it with dedication, pride, and professionalism.
Smokey Yunick should also be in the first class and some of the important cars should also be on display.
The cars should include Red Byron's 1949 Daytona Beach winning car, the winged Plymouths and Chargers, Junior Johnsons "Yellow Banana," and Smokey's 7/8ths "scale" #13 Chevelle and Pety's 200th winning car.
Posted by: Marc | Mar 8, 2006 4:41:06 PM
Hey, Dave Marcis should be included, he "did so much with so little,he hung in for four decades with nothing". He was one of the last independents, ran in over 880 races(second to Richard Petty), started the Daytona 500 times.....a record. If you can't see fit to include Dave, at least exhibit his "wingtip driving shoes".
Posted by: Paul Lay | Mar 8, 2006 6:03:39 PM
Hey, Dave Marcis should be included, he "did so much with so little,he hung in for four decades with nothing". He was one of the last independents, ran in over 880 races(second to Richard Petty), started the Daytona 500 32 times.....a record. If you can't see fit to include Dave, at least exhibit his "wingtip driving shoes".
Posted by: Paul Lay | Mar 8, 2006 6:05:22 PM
i know the drivers, crew chiefs, engine builders, and the like are going to get their rightful place in the new hall, but, if there aint a place for Mr. Tom Higgins then "there wont be no fame in that danged ol' hall.
Posted by: sandyg | Mar 8, 2006 7:59:24 PM
Thanks Tom for ALL of the glorious storied, I agree THERE should be Sports writers who helped bring the sport to the masses, Promotors, Crew Chiefs, Choclate Gasman, oops,you know the whole enchilada...mmmm I don't recall hearing Ralph Earnhardt mentioned.
Posted by: Fan # 5 | Mar 8, 2006 8:06:10 PM
I think the REALLY important issue is defining the process by which people get elected. The Rock'n'Roll HoF mandates seven elected every year. Baseball calls for a given percentage of votes. I like the baseball system better. Make it a tough vote, thus a meaningful vote. And please, please, PLEASE: no fan voting! Otherwise Dale Jr. will be in ahead of Curtis Turner and Herb Thomas. Pick a solid group of voters, add members of the Hall every year, and pretty soon, between writers and members, you have a knowledgeable group whose choices will deserve respect.
Posted by: Doug | Mar 8, 2006 11:30:44 PM
As usual Tom you have my amens from the congregation. I would like to second the nomination for Tom Higgins and bring Barney Hall, John Holman, Ralph Moody, Banjo Matthews, Cotton Owens and Bud Moore to the vote.
Posted by: Mike | Mar 9, 2006 8:01:57 AM
Yes Tom Higgins should be in there.
Posted by: Diane Sadler | Mar 9, 2006 9:11:46 AM
Many of my first ballot candidates have already been mentioned. However, since your talking about firsts, how about car owner Raymond Parks and his driver Lloyd Seay. Parks was way ahead of his time in always insisting his cars had the "first class/professional/ business like appearance" while his driver Lloyd Seay has been described by Bill France Sr. as the greatest driver he has ever seen.
Off the top of my head I don't believe Lloyd "technically" drove in a NASCAR race as he was killed, very young, shortly before the NASCAR organization was formed. However, I believe he was the first superstar driver of the group that was to become NASCAR a year or so after his death.
Posted by: doug | Mar 9, 2006 9:16:47 AM
Let's not forget Junie Dunlavey...whoelse gave so many the chance to been seen and advance in NASCAR?
Posted by: little al | Mar 9, 2006 10:37:30 AM
Everyone has their favorites FOR induction, and also some discusion of protocal on how to proceed with it. I would like to take exception to Tom's mentioning Bruton Smith. I'ld just like to remind you that the best hitter in baseball is not in their hall because of gambling. Mr Smith will always be remembered by me as the main force behind closing Rockingham and North Wilksboro!!!!!
Posted by: Jaun | Mar 9, 2006 11:25:32 AM
Hal Hamrick, J.D. McDuffie, Jimmy Means, Paul Sawyer, Joe Weatherly, Fireball Roberts, the list is endless....and I third the invite to Tom Higgins. They should induct 10 every year........2 media, be it TV/radio/written; 1 promotor/track owner; 2 car owner/driver;3 drivers from pre Winston Cup era(1972) and 1 driver from modern era (1973 until now). Now before you start yelling about not enough drivers, remember back in the early days, the driver was the car owner.....Richard Childress, Lee & Richard Petty, etc. Just a thought.
Posted by: Fran | Mar 9, 2006 12:05:25 PM
Fran said in part, " They should induct 10 every year........2 media, be it TV/radio/written; 1 promotor/track owner; 2 car owner/driver;3 drivers from pre Winston Cup era(1972) and 1 driver from modern era (1973 until now). "
I disagree 100%, Fran, sorry. No one should get in just because they need to have a ceremony. If the voters don't want to elect someone some year, that's OK by me. Of course, setting forth categories of eligibility is probably a good idea. Should people be eligible as both driver and owner? Or (tongue firmly in cheek) as crew chief and driver (Kirk Shelmerdine)? Or should a person be elected, period?
I get into this argument elsewhere in life, but I believe in setting the bar high and then letting the voters take over. Otherwise you have the dreaded quotas. As I said, I like baseball's system: if 75% of the voters say you're in, you're in. They don't make it "50% if no one gets more than that."
Now that I've made THAT clear, how about Carl Kiekhaefer? And why am I cynical enough to think that the whole thing will be a commercial boondoggle, with fan polls and the like?
Posted by: Doug | Mar 9, 2006 5:46:21 PM
As per normal, everyone has their opinion. Nascar, even with all of their growing problems, has stayed within the realm of giving a product that the normal man can afford. Try going to an NBA, NFL, MLB, NHL, game and not paying major dollars over and above what you will pay for Nascar tickets. I agree that ticket prices are out of control, "bumper car drivers" are out of control, and Nascar protects their "golden boys" !!!!!!!! But it's still racing. You could watch WWF, WWE, or pay per view boxing. THAT'S REAL.....
Posted by: jim | Mar 10, 2006 4:31:22 PM
I agree with those who say the MLB process is the way to go. Let's not have a ceremony just for ceremony sake. Let's have a time period after retirement (say 5 years) to give a driver's career some perspective. Let's define the voting panel among an elite group of journalists and inductees. Let's keep the vote at a certain percentage. If there are three in one year, then there are three. If there are none, so be it. There are so many eligibles, especially since there is 55 years of NASCAR history to account for, but how many have 'hall' numbers and influence on the sport? They may have been flashes of greatness, but had a career cut short. In the NFL, the same thing happened to Terrell Davis - great running back, Super Bowl MVP, but he got hurt and probably does not have 'hall' numbers. Same with Davey Allison, perhaps. A great, but tragically short career. Did he amass "hall" numbers even without a championship? Did Tim Richmond?
I truly hope the process is set so that induction really means something, and isn't just another commercial boondoggle for the France Family.
And by all means, Tom Higgins on the first ballot for media/writers/historians of NASCAR!
Posted by: BARman | Mar 10, 2006 4:44:50 PM
As someone who saw his first NASCAR race in 1950 at the now defunct Langhorne Speedway I can recommend the whole Flock family of racers. Please don't forget some of the great dirt tracks. Old time Modified drivers like Frankie Schneider who won more than 700 races in a long career.
Posted by: Tom Bonner | Mar 12, 2006 8:06:18 AM
Don't forget one of the BEST stock car drivers I have ever seen...Red Farmer
Posted by: Timm | Mar 13, 2006 4:38:58 AM
Once again gerat writing. I agree with all but what about Tiny Lund and Leroy Yarbrough!And I agree Tom Higgins!
Posted by: Wayne R | Mar 13, 2006 3:23:10 PM
I think the first year a large group should be inducted so fans visiting the Hall have something to see. Who wants to go the first few years and only see 5 or 10 members.
Posted by: RS7 | Mar 18, 2006 4:27:12 PM
Post a comment
Advertisements
Subscribe to this blog's feed