« DEI/MB2, Deal or No Deal? | Main | This Silly Season Talk Is Silly. »
June 08, 2006
Attacking NASCAR isn’t working
By Mike Harper
If you had a chance to attend the Indianapolis 500 would you go? Let me rephrase the question. If you were a NASCAR fan living outside Indiana and you were given the opportunity to attend the "greatest spectacle on earth" would you go? Call me crazy, but this year I said no. Even though I find the IRL entertaining, I’m not a big supporter. From past experiences, the drivers aren’t accessible like they are in NASCAR and the environment at the track isn’t as user friendly like it is at a NASCAR event. To be honest, I just prefer the low rumble of stock car engines that shake your insides versus the high pitched engine of an open wheel car.
According to Nielsen Media Research, NASCAR’s Coca-Cola 600 had a higher television rating than the Indy 500. In addition, there were plenty of empty seats at Indy. That said and while I’m still being brave, I’ll just say I don’t think the Indy 500 is the greatest spectacle on earth - anymore. Sorry IRL fans, it’s not personal it’s just my opinion. Since I started writing columns many years ago, I’ve received my share of personal attacks from those who disagree with my viewpoints. I ignore them because it comes with the territory. I’m sure others including NASCAR, has a full mailbox of negative letters coming to them on a daily basis. In general, I try to keep my opinions about drivers, NASCAR or any other racing series on a professional level. If I disagree with them or I think they’re wrong, I say it. I don’t use personal slaps to get my point across and I don’t take too kindly when personal slaps are thrown at me or in the faces of others. Sure we kid around sometimes, but at times personal attacks can be taken too far and can’t be ignored. In the case of retired driver Willy T. Ribbs, who I have the utmost respect for, I can’t ignore his choice of words when he called NASCAR, "al-Qaida." (David Poole’s story about Willy T. Ribbs) NASCAR has always been an easy sport to pick on. Non-fans have used negative names to describe NASCAR fans and I’m cool with that. In most cases, I don’t take it too seriously and I can laugh about it because they have every right to hold their opinion. And, at times it’s funny! However, I do take exception to Mr. Ribbs’ comment. He has every right to hate NASCAR and he can trash the sport until the cows come home. But in my eyes, he’s unfairly compared NASCAR to a group of people who make a living as terrorists, killing innocent people and attempting to take freedom away from free loving people. They attacked our country on 9-11, they continue to kill our soldiers and innocent people and people shouldn’t use their name so lightly. Calling NASCAR "al-Qaida" is frankly over the line. Call the sport whatever you want, but remember that NASCAR is an American sport built on American dreams. NASCAR may have their problems, but calling it a name of a group who promotes death to all Americans was unnecessary. That said, congratulations to all of those involved in the ending the terror of al-Qaida’s Abu Musab al-Zarqawi. He WAS the most-wanted terrorist in Iraq. The world is now a better place with him gone.
June 8, 2006 | Permalink
Comments
I found it funny that immediately after Hornish won the Indy 500, the press immediately started asking if he was going to make the jump to Nascar. That just shows what the hierarchy of racing is here in the U.S. No one ever asks the Daytona 500 winner, "so now are you gonna jump to IRL?"
Posted by: Funny | Jun 8, 2006 1:45:21 PM
Mike,
Thousands of NAPA part #723415MWs were involved in the demise of Zarqawi. NAPA has since come out with part #723415MWC. Tiny combs for the MW series as a reward.
Posted by: Keith | Jun 8, 2006 1:52:25 PM
Funny
I didn't think it was funny
When Sam was a free agent in the IRL and b/4 he signed with Penske he was courted by DEI and it came down to a big signing deal but was squashed by CEO of DEI at the last minute
Posted by: funny2 | Jun 8, 2006 2:34:10 PM
And your point is?? My point is that once an IRL driver wins Indy it seems like the media believes that there's nothing left for him/her to do except go to Nascar.
Posted by: and? | Jun 8, 2006 3:10:19 PM
Mike,
I think the mafia would be a fairer comparison for NASCAR.
Posted by: Bill B | Jun 8, 2006 3:47:33 PM
And you repect willy t. ribbs?? seems to me he had his chance and couldn't cut it so he cried foul-poor poor minority. and you want "that there di-ver-si-t?? Let 'em stick to round ball.
Posted by: wayne morgan | Jun 8, 2006 4:18:05 PM
I'll take a BUD and a Brat over a Chardoney and Salmon any day, If it ain't got fenders it ain't racin! I'll take my NASCAR style racin' IS a contact sport.
Posted by: Tbfka# 5 | Jun 8, 2006 5:33:36 PM
Actually I've found the IRL guys to put more of an effort into reaching out to fans when they can. That Indianapolis doesn't out-do Charlotte in ratings anymore has to do less with the IRL - which has actually made open wheel racing worth watching again - than with the general deterioration of open wheel racing before IRL was formed and the belligerence of NASCAR marketing.
NASCAR racing for the most part is inferior right now to IRL. When NASCAR and IRL race on the same tracks - Miami, The Brickyard, Texas, Kansas, Michigan, Kentucky, Fontana when it hosted IRL races, and Chicagoland - IRL usually has the better race.
Willy T. Ribbs' comment about NASCAR being "Al Qaida" is just typical of Willy T. Ribbs, a failed race driver who apparantly feels he is owed something by the sport even though he's never contributed anything worthwhile to it. Janet Guthrie is like that as well - I remember her letters to the NY Times in 1980-1 screaming about how sponsors were going to "male" drivers, and she recently griped about how "cold" Richard Petty was when they met. Guthrie and Ribbs have chips on their shoulders but can't face up to being failures.
Posted by: Mike Daly | Jun 8, 2006 6:28:15 PM
"... a failed race driver who apparantly feels he is owed something by the sport even though he's never contributed anything worthwhile to it."
Come on Daly you can't be series. Ribbs had a very successful career driving for Dan Gurney in IMSA and the old SCCA Trans-Am Series where he was Rookie of the Year in ‘83. He also won more races (seventeen) than any other Trans-Am driver from 1984 to 1986.
"never contributed?" Not hardly.
However when his comments first hit the wires I took him ot task for them. To use the comparisan of NASCAR as anything close to al-Qaida is absurd.
And his using NASCAR's racial bias as a reason for his failing in NASCAR is just as absurd. He failed because the sponsors at the time, and most if not all the owners except Bill Cosby backed away from supporting an African American.
To whine and cry about NASCAR's racial bias at the time when he himself suffered from open wheels same affliction is delusional, at best.
Posted by: Marc | Jun 8, 2006 7:42:06 PM
I am in your back pocket on this Harper. Well said.
Posted by: Mark | Jun 8, 2006 8:13:03 PM
Marc, stop it. "He won more Trans-Am races..." Like hell he did.
How serious a racer was he? When Bruton lined up a car for him in the 1978 World 600 he skipped two scheduled test sessions and later was busted for DUI while driving up a one-way street the wrong way. Dodge lined him up for a goiod Truck Series ride in 2001 and what did he do? Stroked it, just rode around, didn't try to do anything.
He never contributed in racing. He was a failure, always had a chip on his shoulder, and his comparison of NASCAR to Al Qaida shows what a useless person he is. He was a failure - just accept that fact and move on.
Posted by: Mike Daly | Jun 9, 2006 12:31:26 AM
Mike, I would love the chance to go to the Indy 500, and I love the sound of open wheel cars. That's why I'm already planning for the St. Pete Grand Prix in '07.
For many years people have called me a redneck, and other things I shouldn't type, cuz I was attending races before it was cool. Now they are the ones standing in line and paying the big bucks to get into the Daytona 500, while I'm sitting home remembering the good old days.
But Mr. Ribbs making such a statement is not cool. Thanks for bringing this to our attention. I certainly have a different opinion of him now.
Posted by: Shirley | Jun 9, 2006 8:26:56 AM
Greatest spectacle in sports? Huh? I kinda like the IRL, especially at Richmond, however, anyone who thinks the Indy 500 is the greatest spectacle in sports has never been to the Daytona 500. 43 cars, 2 and 3 wide at 190 mph in the first laps of Daytona is truly the Greatest Spectacle in Sports.
Posted by: Scott | Jun 9, 2006 10:54:07 AM
Scott, IMO the Indy 500 WAS the "Greatest Spectical in Sports." But that's when there were more than 33 cars qualifying for the race, and the entire month of May was part of the "Greatest Spectical in Sports."
You think Daytona at 190 is great. You should have been there when it was 200+. I still have a speed chart that goes up to 220. That was BEYOND great!
Posted by: Shirley | Jun 9, 2006 11:38:04 AM
"Even though I find the IRL entertaining, I’m not a big supporter. From past experiences, the drivers aren’t accessible like they are in NASCAR and the environment at the track isn’t as user friendly like it is at a NASCAR event"
PLEASE! The IRL drivers are way more accessible - for 25 bucks i can walk thru the paddock and garage area at Homestead Miami and meet all of the drivers and owners. Also, at indy, I don't have to wait in to go to the bathroom (they even have toilet paper in indy), nor does my wife (unlike daytona). At indy, I can also buy something to eat without everything being sold out. I do love nascar but the IRL events are by far more fan friendly.
Posted by: Sammy | Jun 9, 2006 12:56:34 PM
Sorry to bother everyone but I'm looking for some guidance. I have the following items that are going to be sold in a July Auction but I don't know if there are any Racing/NASCAR organizations or private websites that allow advertising of such things to their members. Can anyone give me some URLs to check into?
Thanks for your help.
patsouth@go-concepts.com
ITEMS TO BE SOLD AT AUCTION SPRINGBORO OHIO JULY 22, 2006 STARTING AT 10 A.M.
Indy 500 Programs (1961-1992), Many Daytona 500 Programs, Darlington, Bristol and other major tracks, Many Cincinnati Reds yearbooks, Many Indy 500 Year Books, Many NASCAR Illustrated Magazines
Posted by: RaceMemorbilia | Jun 9, 2006 6:36:53 PM
Bill Cosby was a car owner in NASCAR??????????!!!!!!!!!!?????
Posted by: Tony29Fan | Jun 10, 2006 3:02:36 AM
Tony29Fan, yes he was. He co-owned Willy T. Ribbs' car in the early 1990s.
Posted by: Mike Daly | Jun 10, 2006 11:17:58 PM
Post a comment
Advertisements
Subscribe to this blog's feed