« The Great Padding Debate | Main | Unleash the sponsorless Crocker »
November 01, 2006
Chase is Working
Way back when the Chase points system was introduced I was a critic of changing the point’s format. The last few years have proven to me that a "playoff" type system makes things much more interesting. There are probably still some critics out there but it is hard to argue that 84 points separating the top 5 drivers is much more exciting than one driver leading by some huge margin. I think that the Championship will come down to the last lap of the Homestead race and that is the way it should be.
The NASCAR Busch Series had an unfortunate situation this year with the championship being clinched so early, but you have to give it to Harvick and his teams, they were on their game this year. I have heard a lot of people say that they need the same system for the Busch Series but I really don’t think it would work the same. There is such a mixture over there with all of the Cup drivers that I don’t think it would build the same type of excitement. I will say that it could be worth a try if someone is going to win the points by 600 plus points.
NASCAR has done a great job with the creation of the Chase. I like to think of it as a playoff system but I am not sure they like it to be used in that context. The reason I think of it that way is simple. During the NCAA basketball tournament you might have a team that wins the tournament that had a rough start to the season or you might have the team with the best record win the championship. At least more that one team had a chance to compete and maybe even show that they could recover from a few bad games. They still have to win the most games in the tournament. Some teams are better than others but you have to be the best team once you qualify for the tournament. The NCAA does not just go ahead and crown the team with the best record before that team goes through the tournament. The Chase reminds me a lot of a playoff system. It is as close as NASCAR Nextel Cup racing could get to a playoff system.
Overall I like the system, but like anything, I have my ideas on some things that might need to be changed or at least tweaked. First, I think winning races needs a little bit more of a bonus. Maybe it is just five more points, just like leading a lap, or leading the most laps but there should be more of a reward for winning. Next, I would give bonus points for the top three qualifiers or at least give the pole winner 3 to 5 points as a bonus. Let’s face it, qualifying is boring. I like the number of drivers in the Chase and the formula for being within 400 points of the leader after the 26th race but I think it could be expanded to maybe 500 points. You don’t want to water it down or make it where too many drivers make it but there could be a few more Chase qualifiers.
Should the previous year’s champion be automatically in the Chase? Or in if he is in the top 15 or so. I am just throwing that out there but I think the champion from the year before should be included somehow. It just so happens that the champ from last year did not get in but is in contention for the 11th place bonus. I think it would add to the hype a little if the year’s previous champion was in the Chase.
Look, I am just throwing my ideas out there. Some of them are pretty far fetched but I am sure we all have some things we want to change. NASCAR does a good job with all of this but it can’t hurt to have our own thoughts about how to make it better.
Who will peak at the right time?
I think the next three races play in favor of Jimmy Johnson and Dale Earnhart Jr. I guess we will see!
The Dale Jarrett Racing Adventure is visiting the Talladega Superspeedway for the next two weekends. Call 888-GO-RACE-1 or visit us online at www.racingadventure.com to book for November 11 or 12. The Holidays are near so order a DJRA gift certificate today!
November 1, 2006 | Permalink
Comments
Maybe, if it came down to the most deserving drivers fighting at Homestead I'd think it was exciting. The Chase lets non-contenders play for a title. Look at where these drivers are in real points...Gordon, just for example, 11th. He deserved a title shot? Stewart, now closing on 3rd in points wont sit at the head table. It lessens the excitement of the last ten events as TV just covers the top 10. It's 1/4 of the season where undeserving top 10 drivers are rewarded positions they would have lost.
Posted by: Keith | Nov 1, 2006 11:12:39 AM
My mine problem is that the chase take away from the races in the beginning. I think if you win more than two races in a season you are in the chase. It wouldn't effect the number of cars that much maybe one or two more. As much as it pain me to say this, last year champion must earn his way into the chase by winning races or being constant. There is no free ride into the chase.
Winning the race should give you more points than the guy who finish second and lead the most laps. This would give more emphasis on team planning for the race. Lay in the back of Super speedways is the plan for some drivers. The only problem with is that we would only care about the last 20-10 laps of a race.
Winning a pole is more of owner thing. I think only owner points be awarded for those that win the poll. It wouldn't effect the driver standings that at all.
Posted by: WBinCC | Nov 1, 2006 12:32:26 PM
The comments to this entry are closed.
Advertisements
Subscribe to this blog's feed