« The rise and fall (or not) of dictators | Main | Crisis of leadership, quality of product »
June 27, 2009
Danica still a work in progress in the IRL
By DAVID GREEN
Five years have flown past since Danica Patrick burst onto the scene by becoming the first woman to lead the Indianapolis 500. "Danica Mania" has cooled a bit, but the 27-year-old is still one of American auto racing's hottest commodities.
For sure, there's anything but a consensus about Patrick's talents as a driver. She is without a doubt pretty good; you just don't go out and lead the Indy 500 and finish fourth as a rookie without having some idea of what the job entails.
Critics, though, have plenty to work with. She has only one career victory; she has moved from team to team, always seeming to have conflicts with one group and opting for greener pastures elsewhere; she is confrontational with competitors and even teammates and can be testy with the media.
All that aside, she is one of the top commodities in sport right now.
The IRL IndyCar Series is in NASCAR country at Richmond (Va.) International Raceway tonight, and Danica's visit comes at a time of great curiosity about her future. A NASCAR ride is one of the possibilities fans are pondering.
In Paul Woody's story in the Richmond Times-Dispatch, the writer concludes that Danica should take advantage of the chance to switch to NASCAR.
Here's hoping that she doesn't.
I hate it that big-time racing has evolved past the point at which drivers could try their hand in other series without turning their backs completely on others. But that's the world we live and race in nowadays. That makes decisions such as the one Patrick is facing so much more important.
Dario Franchitti was fortunate to come out of his NASCAR struggle with a top IRL ride. I'm convinced Franchitti is a better driver than his NASCAR resume suggests. The number of people who have excelled in multiple disciplines of motor sport is very small indeed. But his stock car racing endeavor was a flop.
The bottom line is that Danica does not have the kind of success in IndyCars that Franchitti and several others have achieved. Once she conquers the IRL -- by becoming a consistent winner and, if not champion, at least a contender -- then she can take a look at other challenges.
Until then, it's hard to defend charges that she's exploiting her celebrity because she doesn't really have the talent.
I'm one who believes she has talent. Moving to another series would be the worst way to attempt to prove that she does.
June 27, 2009 | Permalink
Comments
If she wanted to dabble in the Truck or Nationwide series I say great. Cup racing would be her downfall as it was for the others who recently gave it a try. Of course, I doubt she would want to go that route.
Posted by: 68 ss camaro | Jun 27, 2009 9:58:00 PM
She doesn't have talent. She's always had superior racecars in IRL and does less with more than anyone else. She never races anyone, whines constantly over the radio, never offers feedback that actually helps improve the car, and got here only because of her gender. She didn't get here because of talent.
Posted by: Mike Daly | Jun 29, 2009 12:30:19 PM
I believe you have to have talent to drive a race car, NASCAR, IRL or whatever. You don't just sit in a 1,500 lb car and go 220 mph around IMS with 32 other cars without having talent. However, before Danica decides to come to NASCAR maybe she should have a long conversation with Sara Fisher.
And if this is a ploy on Danica's part to get more money on her next contract, she had better sign a good one because this is the second time she has done this and probably the last time it will work.
As for Dario Franchitti, I think he could have worked out better in NASCAR as he was beginning to get better when he had that crash that broke his leg and took him out of the car and then lost sponsorship money while out of the car and the team shut down.
But however it plays out, I just want to see good racing regardless of who is driving the cars.
Posted by: Peter | Jun 30, 2009 7:28:38 AM
I can argue it both ways. If she wants the Big Bucks and doesn't mind falling flat on her face to get them, then welcome to Cup! If she wants to win at all, soon, stick with IRL. If she wants to win in NASCAR, then sign a three-year deal and run the first year (at least) in the lower series, then run a few Cup races in year 2 before going full time in year 3.
And if she wants to win in NASCAR, then she has to find a top team ready to spend the time on her. Hendrick, Roush, Gibbs, Childress (this is a minor setback), Ganassi, Penske. Don't bother with the rest.
Idle question: isn't Montoya's contract up this year? What will he do next year? I hope he sticks around.
Posted by: Doug in CA | Jun 30, 2009 8:57:08 PM
Seriously, could she really do any worse then Scott Speed, Casey Mears or Mikey Boy.
Posted by: 68 ss camaro | Jul 1, 2009 7:00:38 PM
68, if reaching Casey Mears status is what she wants, then she should certainly stay in IRL!
Posted by: Doug in CA | Jul 1, 2009 8:28:46 PM
68: As for your original comment, the financial motivation (obviously part of all this) isn't there for those series. As for your second comment, Danica would probably be pretty pumped to have two Daytona 500 victories to her credit. (I assume "Mikey Boy" is the Waltrip fellow.)
Mike: I know your feelings about Danica and I'm not surprised by this comment. Actually, with AGR she is in second-rate IRL equipment this year and is doing pretty nicely with it. Penske and Ganassi rule IRL now.
Peter: I agree with you that anybody who achieves anything remotely close to finishing in the top five at Indy and winning an IndyCar race can never be acused of having "no talent." Doesn't make you the greatest ever, but it establishes you as waaay better (apologies to Wendy's) than just any old wanna-be. I also concur about Dario. I think he's a really good driver, and a cool guy to boot.
Doug: I don't know if the stairstep approach is best anymore or not. The lower-tier series have lost too much luster -- and, for that matter, are too filled with Cup-level talent, at least in Nationwide. But maybe you're right, as you definitely are regarding the team selection issue. Also, I'm on board with you regarding Montoya. He's won his spurs in NASCAR, as far as I'm concerned. Let's get Kevin Harvick's opinion on that...
Posted by: David Green | Jul 2, 2009 10:43:37 AM
The only reason NASCAR want's her is to try and get back to whee they were before dipsh*t Brian France took over. She will never make it in nascar,she is half assed in the IRL but she is good looking so she gets press. Let her stay where she is and lean to be a little more of a team player and realize she is not near the driver she thinks she is.
Posted by: Snafu | Jul 2, 2009 1:15:45 PM
Post a comment
Advertisements
Subscribe to this blog's feed